VTL § 1174-A — Owner Liability (School Bus Stop‑Arm Camera)

VTL § 1174-A is New York’s owner‑liability statute for school bus stop‑arm camera tickets. It is a ticket that is mailed to the owner or a vehicle that passes a school bus. When a bus displays its flashing red lights and the stop arm is extended, vehicles must stop. If a camera records a violation, a civil notice of liability is mailed to the vehicle’s registered owner—even if the owner was not driving. These cases are civil, carry no points, and are not criminal offenses.

Penalties for VTL § 1174-A (Owner‑Liability)

The statute authorizes fixed civil penalties. There are no DMV points and no jail because this is a civil infraction, not a misdemeanor.

• First violation (within an 18‑month look‑back): $250
• Second violation (within 18 months): $275
• Third & subsequent (within 18 months): $300

Note: Local programs may also impose administrative fees for late responses or non‑payment. The civil liability is against the vehicle owner unless a statutory defense applies.

Statute

The relevant subsection of the Vehicle and Traffic Law can be found here: VTL § 1174-A:

§ 1174-A. Owner liability for failure of operator to stop for a school bus displaying a red visual signal and stop-arm.

Common Defenses & Issues We Review

• Opt‑in authority: Whether the county/school district lawfully authorized its stop‑arm program.
• Notice & mailing timelines: Was the notice of liability issued and mailed within statutory time limits?
• Image clarity & timing: Do photos/video show red signals active and the stop arm extended at the exact moment?
• Vehicle ID: Plate legibility, make/model match, and whether the vehicle was actually in motion past the bus.
• Location exceptions: Site geometry or conditions that may create statutory exceptions.
• Equipment certification & chain of custody: Device testing, calibration, and evidence handling.
• Owner defenses: Statutory defenses (e.g., vehicle was reported stolen) and procedures to transfer liability when applicable.

An experienced traffic attorney can analyze your evidence, raise procedural and technical challenges, and pursue dismissal or a favorable outcome.

Should I Retain Counsel to Fight a School Bus Camera Ticket?

Short answer is no. Camera tickets do not go on a driving record, do not have points, and do not impact insurance rates. There is just a fine. The fee to retain a lawyer to fight the ticket is typically greater than the fine, thus making the endeavor not cost effective.

Benjamin Goldman Law Office

The Benjamin Goldman Law Office is a New York State traffic ticket defense firm. We handle traffic ticket cases anywhere in New York State. For example, in the Buffalo Region we appear for motorists in Allegany; in the Capital Region we regularly cover Altona; in NYC, we cover all of the 5 boroughs; on Long Island we help motorists in Bayville; and in Upstate New York we are available for all of Allen. Consultations are always free.

When you reach out to us about your ticket, one of the first things we consider is whether it makes sense for you to retain an attorney. If the total monetary consequences are less than the legal fee we will advise against retaining our firm.

Contact Us CALL NOW FIGHT YOUR TICKET NOW