New York Traffic Law Community

Community Discussions

Read questions from drivers and responses from the Benjamin Goldman Law Office. Select any preview to open the full discussion.

143
questions
53
active topics
92
discussion pages
Recent community questions

New York Traffic Discussions

These are read-only previews. Open a card to read the complete thread or participate on its discussion page.

VTL 1180(d), Speeding

Posted by Anonymous · November 13, 2024

Can I get my speeding ticket thrown out because the court dates kept getting moved? I got the ticket in 2020 and pleaded not guilty. I rescheduled the first two dates, but the court has postponed it three times since then. It has been four years, can it be dismissed because of those delays?

Attorney response

Your situation is not unique at the Traffic Violations Bureau and will not in of itself be grounds for dismissal. https://www.suspendedlicensenyc.com/blog/new-york-city-traffic-violations-bureau.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1110(a), Disobeying a Traffic Control Device

Posted by Anonymous · November 14, 2024

I was pulled over in New York and the officer gave me a ticket for disobeying pavement markings. There is no fine amount listed on it. What does that mean?

Attorney response

Would need to see the ticket to know for sure but it sounds like you charged with VTL 1110a. https://trafficlawyerlongisland.com/blog/vtl1110a.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(d), Speeding

Posted by Anonymous · November 25, 2024

Speeding ticket appeal problem? A few months ago, after my NYC court date had been postponed for about five years, the court found me guilty and put 4 points on my license. I was never told why I was found guilty, who the judge was, or what I needed to do to appeal or where to file it. I spent days trying to track down the decision, the fine information, and the appeal process myself. I had submitted several defenses in my written statement, the SIOPA, but I still have no idea why they were ignored. Then my appeal was denied too. I explained that I had…

Attorney response

The next step would be to file an Article 78 petition in Supreme Court, but that is more expensive and has low odds of success. Sorry it may have been a good idea to have an attorney involved from day one.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(d), Speeding

Posted by Anonymous · November 25, 2024

My 18-year-old son got his first speeding ticket on the Cross Island Parkway. The officer says radar showed him doing 75 in a 50. Is it worth hiring a lawyer to contest it, and is there any possibility of reducing the points?

Attorney response

Yes there is. An attorney can go to court in his place and should be able to at least get some points off. The ticket is probably returnable to the Queens Traffic Violations Bureau. https://www.suspendedlicensenyc.com/blog/new-york-city-traffic-violations-bureau.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(d), Speeding

Posted by Anonymous · December 8, 2024

What happens with my speeding ticket if the officer mixed up my names? I have two last names, but the ticket lists my first last name as my first name and puts my second last name in the last-name spot.

Attorney response

It will probably hit your record upon conviction as the DMV mostly follows the driver license number. You can file a motion to dismiss for facial insufficiency.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(d), Speeding

Posted by Anonymous · January 8, 2025

I was pulled over for speeding in 2023, but the officer checked my license and registration and told me I was only getting a warning. Now, almost two years later, I got a notice saying my license is going to be suspended because I missed a court date. I never received a ticket or anything from the court telling me when to appear. What should I do?

Attorney response

Sounds like the officer lied. For now you have to treat it as if you received the ticket. An attorney can help with all this. Technically it should be thrown out because you were not served personally with the ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-03(a)(1), Failed to Yield to a Vehicle or Pedestrian

Posted by Anonymous · February 29, 2020

I received a ticket this morning for violation 4-03(A)(1). It says I need to respond within 15 days of the violation date. What should I do?

Attorney response

A guilty plea carries 3 points on your license and may raise your insurance rates. A lawyer can submit a not-guilty response on your behalf and appear in court for you to contest the ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-03(a)(1), Failed to Yield to a Vehicle or Pedestrian

Posted by Anonymous · October 11, 2021

Do I get points for a NYC 4-03(a)(1) ticket? I was stopped at a light at Laurel Hill Boulevard and 58th Street in the right-turn-only lane. When the signal changed, I continued straight under the BQE instead of turning right. An officer pulled me over right away. I understand the ticket for not following the lane markings, and I was thinking of pleading guilty and accepting the fine and points. But I also received a ticket under 4-03(a)(1) for failing to yield to a vehicle or pedestrian. I did not see any pedestrians, and nobody was in the crosswalk. The…

Attorney response

The two tickets carry 2 points and 3 points. Our advice is not to plead guilty to either one. Have a lawyer appear in court for you and attempt to fight both charges.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-03(a)(1), Failed to Yield to a Vehicle or Pedestrian

Posted by Anonymous · November 22, 2023

How do I contest this ticket, and is it possible to do it without hiring a lawyer? I was driving near 135th Street at about 5:30 p.m. when a cop pulled me over and said I did not stop and yield to a pedestrian. I did not notice anyone crossing then. I stopped for the light and continued driving after that.

Attorney response

You are allowed to challenge the ticket on your own. Still, hiring a lawyer may give you a better chance of getting it dismissed, and the lawyer may be able to appear in court for you.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-03(a)(1), Failed to Yield to a Vehicle or Pedestrian

Posted by Anonymous · January 7, 2025

I received a ticket for not yielding to a pedestrian during an emergency. I am a registered nurse with over 35 years of experience, and I was urgently transporting a patient from intensive care to another hospital to save the patient's life. A pedestrian was crossing while looking at his phone, and I drove around him. A police officer stopped me and said I had failed to yield. I showed her my nursing identification, but she said that did not matter. My job is to save lives, not put anyone in danger. She would not listen to me.

Attorney response

If you can prove there was an emergency, then maybe you can get your ticket dismissed.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-03(a)(1), Failed to Yield to a Vehicle or Pedestrian

Posted by Anonymous · June 26, 2026

I was traveling N/B on Amsterdam and took a left onto 96th street (2-way street, 3 lanes in each direction) at 3:00 pm on a weekday. There was a pedestrian crossing 96th street who had just stepped off the NE corner, at least 5 lanes away from me when I turned into the southern-most lane of 96th street. Is this a contestable ticket?? At that time and place, there is always somebody walking in the intersection, which is 6 lanes across.

Attorney response

Technically, it does not matter how wide the road is, but under the right circumstances, a judge can dismiss the ticket if there is no dispute as to the narrative.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(1), Speeding in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · April 27, 2021

What am I supposed to do if my NYC ticket was never put into the system? I got a speeding ticket in October 2019, and almost a year and a half has passed but it still does not show up. I also misplaced the ticket because I had forgotten about it. What should I do?

Attorney response

You can look up whether the ticket has been entered by using your driver license number and the last four digits of your Social Security number.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(1), Speeding in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · August 11, 2021

Can I get a supporting deposition for an NYC TVB moving-violation ticket? I asked the DMV/TVB how to request one and was told their tickets do not use supporting depositions and that it would be handled between me, the officer, and the judge. Is that correct? I assumed I could find out the officer's version before the hearing so I could prepare, but maybe that is just TV-law stuff. In 2018, I was ticketed for speeding 11 to 30 mph over the limit on a two-lane road leading to a highway posted at 50 mph. The officer said the road was 25 mph, but I did not…

Attorney response

A supporting deposition is not available as a matter of right for traffic tickets issued in New York City.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(1), Speeding in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · August 18, 2021

I got an NYC speeding ticket in 2015 for going 10 to 30 over the limit. The hearing has now been pushed to September 2021. Can I get it thrown out because it has taken so long to go to trial?

Attorney response

A speedy-trial argument will not result in dismissal here. A lawyer may appear in court for you and use other legal strategies to seek a dismissal.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(1), Speeding in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · August 15, 2022

Can I get a NYC speeding ticket thrown out because my hearing has been rescheduled over and over for almost three years? I was ticketed in September 2020 for going 38 mph in a 25 mph zone. I entered a not-guilty plea, but the court date keeps being pushed back, and it is now set for June 2023. Does the repeated delay provide a basis to dismiss the ticket?

Attorney response

No. Delays like this are quite common. A lawyer can appear in court for you and contest the speeding charge.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(2), Speeding Over the Posted Limit in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · December 29, 2018

Why hasn't my speeding ticket shown up in the system after nearly seven months? I have a Pennsylvania license and got a ticket in New York City for 73 in a 40. An unmarked vehicle was following closely behind me, so I changed lanes to get away from it. It moved over behind me again, and when I changed lanes a second time, it kept tailgating me. I thought someone might be trying to hurt me, so I accelerated to get past a car on my right and hopefully get away from it. Then the vehicle turned on its lights and pulled me over. I feel like the officer…

Attorney response

A ticket can take quite a while to appear in the system, and in some cases it may never be entered. If there is no ticket in the system, there is nothing to dismiss.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(2), Speeding Over the Posted Limit in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · July 22, 2019

I received a ticket under 4-06(a)(2) after radar clocked me at 63 mph on Woodhaven Boulevard, where the limit was 30 mph. I did not notice the speed limit sign at first. Since I was allegedly 33 mph over, how serious are the penalties?

Attorney response

This is a very serious speeding charge. It carries 8 points. The fines plus driver assessment fees can exceed $1,000. A lawyer can appear in court for you and attempt to challenge the ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
NYCTRR 4-06(a)(2), Speeding Over the Posted Limit in New York City

Posted by Anonymous · November 18, 2020

Can I fight a speeding ticket by pleading not guilty? I was stopped today and the officer said I was doing 75 in a 50. I thought there was some 20-mph allowance in NYC, so I did not think I would be pulled over. He took my license and registration, returned to his vehicle, and gave me a ticket without asking for my explanation. There were cars ahead of me going faster, but when I asked about that, he said I was the only one speeding. The ticket also has the wrong middle initial and lists the wrong state in my address. I do not expect those mistakes to…

Attorney response

Yes. You can, and should, enter a not-guilty plea. An attorney may be able to appear in court for you and could potentially obtain a reduction or possibly a dismissal.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 509(1), Unlicensed Operator

Posted by Anonymous · November 11, 2024

I received an unlicensed-operator ticket in New York, but the plate number written on it is incorrect. Is it worth trying to have the ticket thrown out?

Attorney response

If you were charged with VTL 509-1 you should try to fight it because it goes on your driving record. https://capitalregiontrafficlawyer.com/blog/509-1-unlicensed-operator.html

1 replyOpen discussion
Aggravated Unlicensed Operation in the Third Degree (AUO 3rd)

Posted by Anonymous · June 26, 2026

I have an old ticket (went to court for but still unpaid) of an unlicensed operator from a few years back. Just recently got pulled over again, resulting in AUO 3rd. Wondering what the "usual" or "standard" penalties would be? Also, how much does the fine for the AUO 3rd cost?. Am I better off spending the money for a paid lawyer or just going with a PD? Thanks!

Attorney response

There's no standard across New York State. Depends on a number of factors, including circumstances, history, the judge, the court, the prosecutor, and, of course, the defense attorney.

1 replyOpen discussion
Criminal Penalties for Driving with a Suspended License in New York State

Posted by Anonymous · October 9, 2024

I have suspended New York license and got a ticket in Alabama for driving under Suspension.. Will this affect my ability to get reinstated in New York?

Attorney response

Don't think the Alabama ticket will impact your NY privileges.

1 replyOpen discussion
Criminal Penalties for Driving with a Suspended License in New York State

Posted by Anonymous · December 19, 2024

How do I find a lawyer to help with a traffic ticket for driving with a suspended license?

Attorney response

Best if you retain an attorney with experience handling your specific type of case in the specific court that adjudicated your case.

1 replyOpen discussion
Car Insurance and Traffic Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · November 21, 2024

Can my insurer increase my car insurance in New York because of this? I received a NYC speeding ticket in September 2019 that put 4 points on my license. The hearing kept getting postponed by the state for about five years. When the case was finally decided, I was found guilty even though I had submitted a statement raising several defenses. I had also asked the DMV for one last adjournment so I could attend the Bronx hearing, but that request was denied. I did not receive the decision and did not know which judge decided it, why I was found guilty, or…

Attorney response

sounds typical and I don't see a way out of this. spilled milk at this point, but hiring an attorney from day one could have avoided all this aggravation and increased insurance rates. https://www.upstatenewyorktickets.com/blog/how-do-traffic-tickets-impact-insurance-rates.html

1 replyOpen discussion
Leaving the Scene of an Accident

Posted by Anonymous · November 2, 2024

I got 4 tickets: leaving a scene of a personal injury, following too closely, aggravated unlicensed of the 3rd, and unlicensed operator. This was my first hit and run I did am I going to jail

Attorney response

If the injury is “not serious,” then it is a misdemeanor. If the injury is “serious,” then you can be charged as a felony. Whether you go to jail depends on the nature of the injuries, why you were suspended to begin with, among other factors. Getting an attorney with experience…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1144-a(a), Move Over Law

Posted by Anonymous · November 19, 2024

How much could I be fined for not using due care to avoid crashing into an emergency vehicle? The officer gave me a traffic ticket without a dollar amount and said I could plead guilty so they would mail me the fine. I asked what it would cost, but he would not say. If I plead not guilty, I understand I would have to go to court. I do not live in New York and may not be able to return, but I would pay it if the amount is not too high. How can I plead guilty without knowing what I will owe?

Attorney response

exact fine is up the judge, maximum is $243. https://capitalregiontrafficlawyer.com/blog/move-over-law-vtl-1144aa.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1144-a(a), Move Over Law

Posted by Anonymous · November 27, 2024

What are the fine and surcharge for VTL 1144-a(a) and VTL 1202(B)(2)? I was charged with VTL 1144-a(a) and entered a not-guilty plea. The court then gave me a VTL 1202(B) charge with a $200 fine plus a $25 surcharge. That seems very high, and I am questioning whether pleading not guilty was a mistake. If I had pleaded guilty to VTL 1144-a(a), what fine would I have faced? What fines can apply to VTL 1202(B)? Also, I was told the 1144-a(a) ticket has three points. Since my license and vehicle registration are from Massachusetts and I received the ticket…

Attorney response

VTL 1144aa is a two point ticket and carries a maximum fine of $243. https://capitalregiontrafficlawyer.com/blog/move-over-law-vtl-1144aa.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1144-a(a), Move Over Law

Posted by Anonymous · January 2, 2025

Should I fight a New York Move Over Law ticket even though I am from out of state? My wife and I are staying in Plattsburgh for about a month and then expect to go back home to Florida. My vehicle has Florida registration. On December 30, 2024, I was pulled over near Schroon Lake and given a ticket for allegedly not moving over. I did not see an emergency vehicle, lights, or hear sirens, and I did not know this law applied in that situation. I normally do change lanes when I notice emergency vehicles. The ticket says I need to enter a guilty or…

Attorney response

1.an attorney can go to court in your place 2. max fine is $243 with two points on your license. 3. prosecutors take such charges seriously but a good traffic ticket should be able to be successful in getting the charges reduced to a no point ticket…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1111(d)(1), Red Light Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · June 25, 2024

Can a New York City red light violation hearing be postponed multiple times, and what are the implications of fighting a camera ticket from out of state?

Attorney response

For a New York City red light ticket that was issued by a police officer at a traffic stop, the hearings can indeed be postponed multiple times. However, if we're dealing with a camera ticket, not a ticket issued by a police officer, then it's vital to weigh the costs and hassle…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1111(d)(1), Red Light Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · June 25, 2024

Can NY DOT administratively Postpone Traffic Violation Hearing every year since 2019 and again to 2025? My husband got a red light violation in the mail in 2019. We live in another state where only rear plates are issued. He intended to appear at hearing but it was postponed by them to 2020. Then 2021, again 2022 but with a twist (rescheduled to 2023 but if he wanted plead his case before then, he could complete the enclosed form as his written statement & the judge will decide without a hearing). This also meant if found guilty he would be responsible…

Attorney response

camera tickets don't have points and don't go on your record. if you're paying more in travel costs to fight this ticket then you lost the plot. Also you say "they didn't expect him to want to come to NY to appear before judge to plead his case, by now expected him to give up &…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1111(d)(1), Red Light Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · February 11, 2025

What are the consequences of entering an intersection as the light changes to red and a pedestrian remains in the crosswalk?

Attorney response

If you enter the intersection while the light is green, then you should not get a red light ticket. If you enter the intersection after the light turned red then you can get a red light ticket. Either way, entering an intersection while there is a pedestrian in the crosswalk is…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1111(d)(1), Red Light Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · May 15, 2026

Can incorrect ownership details on a New York red light ticket lead to dismissal?

Attorney response

An error in listing the owner as the driver on a New York red light ticket does not automatically result in dismissal. However, other defenses may be available so best to consult with a traffic ticket attorney.

1 replyOpen discussion
Parking Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · November 14, 2024

I got a parking ticket in Manhasset, North Hempstead, because my car was parked facing against traffic. I was there after a family member passed away, and the ticket was issued at night under violation 65-18. I live out of state. Do I have to pay it, and what could happen if I do not?

Attorney response

the owner of the car may face a civil judgement........................................................

1 replyOpen discussion
Reckless Driving, VTL 1212

Posted by Anonymous · October 4, 2018

I was given a pink summons for reckless driving after an illegal turn. The officer told me I need to appear in court within 10 days, although the court date listed is in December, and said there are no points. But when I looked it up, I saw that it may be 5 points. I am mainly worried that this could leave me with a permanent criminal record because I expect to apply for U.S. citizenship later this year. What should I do?

Attorney response

The officer appears to have given you bad information. Reckless driving is a serious charge: it is criminal and carries 5 points. You may want to speak with a traffic lawyer in the local area. A lawyer can appear in court for you and may be able to have the charge reduced to a…

1 replyOpen discussion
Reckless Driving, VTL 1212

Posted by Anonymous · March 12, 2021

I missed a criminal court date for a reckless driving ticket I got in 2018, and when I was stopped a few days ago, the officer said there is a warrant for me. I have been trying to get this taken care of, even tried to turn myself in, but I do not know what else I am supposed to do. I am supposed to fly to Miami next week. Can I still board the plane without having problems?

Attorney response

If your trip does not involve going through passport control, then the warrant may not come up. But you should work on having the warrant cleared. A lawyer may be able to appear in court for you and handle it without requiring you to go yourself.

1 replyOpen discussion
Reckless Driving, VTL 1212

Posted by Anonymous · June 18, 2022

Reckless driving after turning around on a one-way street I recently moved to the U.S. from Italy, although I am a U.S. citizen and have a passport. While driving in NYC, my GPS sent me onto a one-way street. As soon as I noticed, I tried to make a U-turn, but an officer stopped me with several cars nearby. The officer checked my license and registration and gave me a court ticket for reckless driving. I hired a lawyer for $900, which seems expensive to me. Is it worth having an attorney for this?

Attorney response

That fee is not excessive. Reckless driving is a criminal charge.

1 replyOpen discussion
Reckless Driving, VTL 1212

Posted by Anonymous · July 28, 2023

I was ticketed in Ohio about a year ago for driving 100 in a 70 while I was away from New York. It was listed as reckless driving, but only as a minor misdemeanor. Could that keep me from being allowed into Canada? I have received conflicting information about whether this counts as a criminal record.

Attorney response

You should consult an Ohio traffic ticket attorney and/orCanadian immigration attorney. My guess is that it probably will not affect your entry, but counsel should confirm that.

1 replyOpen discussion
Reckless Driving, VTL 1212

Posted by Anonymous · August 27, 2025

How can a reckless driving charge for a minor in a private parking lot be contested in New York?

Attorney response

Hiring an attorney who specializes in traffic cases in the relevant court can help challenge the charge, especially if evidence like photos exists.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1111(a)(1), Failed to Yield Right of Way on a Green Light

Posted by Anonymous · August 28, 2026

is it a requirement for a NYC TBV guilty determination to cite the statute violated? if it does not, can it be reversed

Attorney response

While unusual, it is not automatic grounds for reversal. To appeal your decision you need to file with the Appeals Unit. See here for more information: https://dmv.ny.gov/tickets/appeal-a-tvb-ticket-conviction Please note that the DMV Appeals Unit has an extremely low reversal…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1120(a), Failed to Keep Right

Posted by Anonymous · November 30, 2018

Can I fight a ticket for not keeping right? I was driving somewhere I do not know well, and the lane markings were very hard to see.

Attorney response

Yes. Enter a not-guilty plea and photograph the location. Being unfamiliar with the area is not a defense, but poorly visible road markings or signs may support your case.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1120(a), Failed to Keep Right

Posted by Anonymous · November 13, 2019

Can I fight a New York VTL 1120(a) ticket when I do not believe I did anything wrong? During rush hour on the Saw Mill Parkway, an officer stopped me for not keeping right. The right lane had constant traffic entering and leaving, so I did not think I could safely move into it. Vehicles in the left lane were also heading toward I-684, and I was on my way home to western Massachusetts. The patrol car had been following very closely behind my Jeep, and I did not realize it was police until I was pulled over, even though the officer said the vehicle was…

Attorney response

You can fight a ticket even if you do not have a defense. A lawyer can appear in court for you and work to prevent points from being added to your license.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1120(a), Failed to Keep Right

Posted by Anonymous · July 28, 2020

Could I get a ticket for briefly driving on the wrong side of the road near a photo-enforced intersection? I was heading down a wide road toward an intersection with cameras. I misunderstood my navigation and started making a left turn onto the wrong street. Once I noticed, I continued on the wrong side until I reached the intersection because there was no traffic coming toward me. Then I moved across three lanes in front of cars stopped at the red light so I could get back to the correct side. I made a right turn on red, which is allowed where I live…

Attorney response

Never heard of a red-light camera giving tickets for any other violations other than red lights. Either way, it will not have points because the camera does not know who was driving.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1120(a), Failed to Keep Right

Posted by Anonymous · July 14, 2021

Should I just plead guilty to two tickets for not keeping right and unsafe driving? Traffic was completely backed up on July 4 because of the fireworks. I had been sitting behind several cars near an intersection for about two hours. The vehicle at the front was not moving even though traffic ahead had started going, so I moved into the left lane and pulled alongside to see what was happening. Right then, an officer stopped me.. I received one ticket for failing to keep right and another for driving unsafely. There was no solid line, and the other car…

Attorney response

A guilty plea, or a conviction after court, can be expensive, especially after you account for the subsequent increased insurance rates. A traffic-ticket lawyer can handle the matter for you and appear in court in your place as necessary.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1120(a), Failed to Keep Right

Posted by Anonymous · December 5, 2023

I was cited last night after pulling out of a gas station in Greenwood Lake for not keeping right, VTL 1120(a). I have not gotten a traffic ticket in more than 20 years, so I am unsure what to do. I plan to plead not guilty and appear in court, but should I request a deposition, or is that unnecessary? I do not want three points or higher insurance costs and want to handle this correctly.

Attorney response

A lawyer can take care of the matter for you, including filing the not-guilty plea, requesting any needed paperwork, and appearing in court on your behalf.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1126(a) Driving to Left of Pavement Markings

Posted by Anonymous · July 9, 2024

I'm a resident of Virginia and came to Niagara Falls over the long weekend. While returning to VA, I was driving on 219 S near Ellicottville, NY, and crossed left of pavement marking to cross another vehicle which was driving roughly at 10 mph in a 40 mph zone. I'd like to understand if the case can be dismissed by any chance or potentially reduce the impact on my driving record. Please let me know my options.

Attorney response

This ticket can be reduced to a parking ticket if handled properly.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1128(c), Failed to Use Designated Lane

Posted by Anonymous · April 21, 2015

I received a moving-violation ticket that says I did not stay in the required lane. What can I do about it? This is my first moving ticket in about 10 to 15 years, and I have to appear in the Village of Airmont, New York, court.

Attorney response

Speak with a traffic-ticket lawyer. A consultation will likely be free, and the overall attorney fee may be more affordable than you expect.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1128(c), Failed to Use Designated Lane

Posted by Anonymous · May 29, 2019

I got a ticket in Cheektowaga, New York for failing to use the proper lane, VTL 1128(c). I am 17, have a Class DJ license, and have never had a traffic ticket before. I stayed in the right lane on a two-lane road and went straight through an intersection, but that lane was marked for right turns only. I was relying on my GPS and did not notice the signs. The two lanes continued straight beyond the intersection, and an officer stopped me afterward. Could this suspend my license? Can I plead not guilty and possibly get a lesser penalty? Is there a fine?

Attorney response

GPS does not always have the most exact current information. Can’t rely solely on GPS. By itself, this ticket should not suspend your license unless there are other violations on your record. See: https://www.benjamingoldmanlawoffice.com/blog/probationary-period-for-new-drivers-i…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1128(c), Failed to Use Designated Lane

Posted by Anonymous · April 9, 2021

I just got my first ticket in New York for not using the designated lane. I was trying to find directions on my phone because I was lost, and I nearly drove into a state trooper before getting pulled over. The trooper was actually very nice. Is there any way to fight this? I really do not want it to raise my insurance rates.

Attorney response

Yes, there are many ways of fighting a traffic ticket. An experienced traffic ticket attorney is in the best position to fight the ticket and can also go to court in your place.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1128(c), Failed to Use Designated Lane

Posted by Anonymous · March 25, 2022

A car ahead of me stopped, so I went around it, through the HOV lane. I got back out of that lane right away, but about half a mile later there were police vehicles and officers stopping drivers. I was pulled over and given ticket for failed to use designated lane. But the officer gave me the ticket without giving me a chance to explain myself. This is my first ticket ever. Should I try to fight it? I cannot tell whether it carries points because the ticket is not showing up in the system yet. Also, the officers were walking among traffic on a busy…

Attorney response

Even if the officers were handling the stop in a dangerous way, that does not affect the ticket. This is a three-point ticket and can be contested on your narrative or other grounds.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1129(a), Tailgating Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · December 6, 2019

How can I be blamed when the car ahead suddenly stopped completely on the highway? She was following the vehicle in front of her too closely and hit her brakes. I tried to stop, but I still struck her car. I was not speeding or tailgating, and it was drizzling.

Attorney response

I’m sorry this happened. The reasoning is that you must leave enough room behind the vehicle ahead so you can stop safely, even if that vehicle brakes abruptly for no apparent reason. Nevertheless you can still fight the ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1129(a), Tailgating Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · February 19, 2020

Can I enter a not-guilty plea for a tailgating ticket? I was driving on a highway where the limit dropped from 55 to 45, then to 30 near an exit. Traffic had been moving quickly, but the cars ahead suddenly stopped at the 30 zone. I braked hard but still bumped the car in front of me, causing only minor damage.

Attorney response

The accident will likely affect your insurance rates, and a tailgating conviction could make that increase worse. You can contest the ticket, and a lawyer can appear in court for you. A lawyer is also best positioned to keep the violation off your driving record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1129(a), Tailgating Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · December 2, 2020

After a small accident in New York, I was cited for following too closely even though the officer did not actually see what happened. I found CPL 140.25 and thought an officer needed to personally observe the offense. Can that ticket still be valid, and if so, what VTL provision allows it?

Attorney response

Not personally observing the alleged violation can be used as a defense in this case.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1129(a), Tailgating Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · August 16, 2024

I was driving to school, listening to music, singing along when a woman pulled out onto the road in front of me. We drove along for approximately 500 feet and then she started flipping me off and brake checking me. On one of the occasions of her brake checking me my foot slipped and instead of hitting the brakes, I accidentally gassed it, rear ending her. Someone witnessedthat witnessed the event and had dashcam footage came forward and I was ultimately cited with "following too closely." I have a strong feeling that the footage only shows what happened…

Attorney response

If handled properly it can get reduced to no points or dismissed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1129(a), Tailgating Tickets

Posted by Anonymous · December 21, 2024

I got a ticket in Windsor, New York for VTL 1129(a), following too closely, after I hit the car ahead of me in heavy highway traffic. The vehicle in front stopped suddenly and I rear-ended it. Should I plead not guilty?

Attorney response

It is a 4 point ticket and will cause hikes in your insurance premiums. Best to fight it.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1140(a), Failed to Yield Right of Way at Intersection

Posted by Anonymous · January 23, 2025

I received a traffic ticket for failing to yield the right of way. I already entered my plea. Do I still need to appear in court? I would like to pay it, but I cannot find the fine amount.

Attorney response

Your question is not entirely clear. If you received this ticket outside of NYC, and you pled guilty, the exact fine is determined by the judge. When the court receives your guilty plea, it will be brought before the assigned judge, who imposes a fine. The court then sends you…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1151(a), Failure to Yield to a Pedestrian in a Crosswalk

Posted by Anonymous · January 11, 2018

The officer wrote the wrong color for my car on the ticket. Does that make a difference, and can I contest it? I was making a left turn and waited for a pedestrian to cross before I continued. About a block later, an officer pulled me over and repeatedly asked for my license but would not tell me why. He stayed in his car for around ten minutes, then returned my papers with a ticket for not yielding to a pedestrian. The vehicle color listed on it is wrong.

Attorney response

It depends on how much the color written on the ticket differs from your vehicle’s actual color. If something like gray instead of silver it is not a big deal. If something like red instead of blue, then the grounds for dismissal are stronger.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1151(a), Failure to Yield to a Pedestrian in a Crosswalk

Posted by Anonymous · October 4, 2018

What does the prosecution need to show for a New York VTL 1151(a) ticket? I got a summons for supposedly not yielding to a pedestrian who was in a crosswalk. My first and middle names are switched on the ticket, my birth date is one day wrong, the sex listed is wrong, and it leaves out my car's color. Could those mistakes lead to a dismissal?

Attorney response

If so much of your personal information is wrong, then the ticket may not have been issued to “you” in the sense that even if you plead guilty, it may not appear on your driving record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1151(a), Failure to Yield to a Pedestrian in a Crosswalk

Posted by Anonymous · August 11, 2023

I received a ticket for not yielding to a pedestrian at a crosswalk. I was already in the intersection making a right turn when the pedestrian approached. I stopped, and the pedestrian also stopped and stepped back onto the sidewalk, away from the crosswalk, so I completed my turn. The officer still gave me a ticket. This is my first offense—can I avoid points on my license?

Attorney response

The facts as you describe them do not appear to constitute a violation of 1151(a), but the ticketing officer may have another narrative. To avoid the points, you would need to contest the ticket in court. An attorney can appear in court for you as needed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1151(a), Failure to Yield to a Pedestrian in a Crosswalk

Posted by Anonymous · June 7, 2024

Can I fight a failure to yield to pedestrian ticket if the pedestrian was an undercover cop? I was driving and came across a blinking yellow traffic light. I noticed a pedestrian and it looked like he was going to walk passed the crosswalk. I continued to drive and then he stepped into the crosswalk as I am crossing the line where traffic should stop at the intersection. I swerve wide so there's no chance of hitting him. Then I get pulled over by an undercover police car, who told me the pedestrian was an undercover cop and that the whole thing was…

Attorney response

You can definitely fight this ticket, but not on the grounds that the pedestrian was an undercover cop.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1160(b), Improper Left Turn (Two-Way Street)

Posted by Anonymous · November 24, 2024

I got two tickets after trying to get onto the Brooklyn Bridge from a short merge lane. Traffic would not make room for me, and I ended up making a double left turn even though I did not want to. The officer gave me one ticket for an improper left turn on a two-way roadway and another for not following pavement markings. Can I be ticketed twice over the same turn?

Attorney response

Sounds like it is redundant and should be fought. Your case will be adjudicated in the Traffic Violations Bureau. An attorney can go to court in your place and try beat the charges. https://www.suspendedlicensenyc.com/blog/new-york-city-traffic-violations-bureau.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1163(a), Improper or Unsafe Turn Without Signal

Posted by Anonymous · February 8, 2019

How many points would I receive in Brooklyn for an improper-turn ticket under VTL 1163(a)?

Attorney response

An improper-turn violation carries 2 points.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1163(a), Improper or Unsafe Turn Without Signal

Posted by Anonymous · May 30, 2019

I got a ticket in the Bronx for making a left turn from the right lane. It says 1163A. How many points does that carry? I already used a defensive driving course, and I know I can only do it once every three years. What can I do to fight the ticket or avoid the points?

Attorney response

In New York, a defensive driving class does not remove or lower points. To avoid the points, you would need to contest the ticket. A lawyer can appear in court for you.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1163(a), Improper or Unsafe Turn Without Signal

Posted by Anonymous · February 23, 2021

Can I contest a 1163(a) ticket? I was cited for making an improper turn, but I did not see any signs saying that turning was prohibited. I came off the eastbound CBE at Webster Avenue in the Bronx. At the end of the ramp, I was in the right of two lanes, had my left signal on, and turned onto northbound Webster Avenue.

Attorney response

You can be charged with improper turn under 1163-a even if there are no signs prohibiting turns.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1163(a), Improper or Unsafe Turn Without Signal

Posted by Anonymous · August 6, 2022

I was stopped at a red light and given a ticket for not using my turn signal, but I did signal. The copy of the ticket I received is basically blank and I cannot read it. Does that affect the ticket?

Attorney response

Show what you got to a traffic ticket attorney to determine if there are grounds for dismissal.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1163(a), Improper or Unsafe Turn Without Signal

Posted by Anonymous · October 20, 2022

Can I fight a ticket for violating VTL 1163(a), or is there any chance of getting it dismissed?

Attorney response

It may be possible to contest the charge. An attorney can evaluate the situation if you provide them with copies of the ticket and more information about what transpired.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1172(a), Stop Sign Violation

Posted by Anonymous · June 23, 2024

What are the chances of having a stop sign violation ticket dismissed in New York?

Attorney response

The likelihood of having a stop sign violation dismissed in New York depends on many factors including the jurisdiction of the alleged violation, the evidence, the specific circumstances of the case, and the arguments made in court. Consulting with an experienced traffic attorney…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1172(a), Stop Sign Violation

Posted by Anonymous · June 23, 2024

What are my chances for getting my ticket dimissed? I went through a stop sign in queens new york,

Attorney response

Too many possible variables to be able to give you a percentage. But passing it along to an experienced traffic ticket attorney increases the odds.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1172(a), Stop Sign Violation

Posted by Anonymous · August 31, 2026

What should I do if I want to contest a stop sign and a speed not reasonable and prudent ticket in Suffolk County?

Attorney response

Both tickets carry three point, which can lead to a driver responsibility assessment fee and higher insurance premiums. Pleading not guilty might be the best approach. An attorney can handle the plea and any necessary court appearances on your behalf.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1174(a), Failed to Stop for a School Bus

Posted by Anonymous · December 6, 2024

Will I be ticketed for passing a school bus? I went by a school bus while its yellow lights were flashing. As I was alongside it, the stop arm started coming out but was only partway extended. The bus lights stayed yellow until we had begun passing, then turned red. I was driving about 20 mph, and when I checked my mirror afterward, the stop arm was fully out.

Attorney response

Sounds like you are in the legal right, whether you will get a ticket is another story. ...............

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1174-A, Owner Liability (School Bus Stop‑Arm Camera)

Posted by Anonymous · August 21, 2024

Passing g stopped school bus that was not able to be seen due to semi trailer next to bus Traveling on Fulton st in Farmingdale in a work truck. School bus had stopped going the other direction. However a semi, with trailer, blocked my ability to see the bus until after I had already passed it. The company got the ticket in the mail, and paid it now I have to pay them for it. Can I still challenge the ticket. Due date for payment was 8/8/24. I just received the notice of it today

Attorney response

cant challenge it after it was paid but it does not go on your record. https://www.trafficlawyerlongisland.com/blog/vtl-1174-a-failed-to-stop-for-school-bus.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1174-A, Owner Liability (School Bus Stop‑Arm Camera)

Posted by Anonymous · July 24, 2026

Notice re: school bus does not show car passing a school bus only shows license plate on back of car but no evidence that car passed a school bus letting children on or off bus & of car which may have been taken anywhere.

Attorney response

Sounds like the evidence is insufficient and the charge should be disputed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding in a 55 MPH Zone

Posted by Anonymous · July 4, 2024

I got a speeding ticket forgoing 88 in a 55. I was wondering how many points it will be and how much it will be ?

Attorney response

That would be eight points. Maximum possible fine of $693+ $450 Driver Responsibility Assessment Fee. Obviously, your insurance rates will go up. An attorney can go to court in your place and work on getting that reduced or dismissed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding in a 55 MPH Zone

Posted by Anonymous · July 9, 2024

What should I do w this traffic ticket in Suffolk County that was 25 over (80 in 55mph);Are there low income helping legal services in NY for traffic tickets, not sure pro bono for something like traffic but not sure of all my options out there. I had a DWI 7 years ago.

Attorney response

Traffic tickets are not eligible for legal aid or a public defender because they are non-criminal in nature

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding in a 55 MPH Zone

Posted by Anonymous · July 15, 2024

What do you recommend doing with my speed ticket? I live in Toronto, and I was on my way to come back home in Buffalo Hwy 290. A police officer pulled me over for speeding two days ago. He told me that I drove 75mil/hr in the area with maximum speed of 55. Consequently, I have to attend to the court (TONAWANDA TOWN COURT) in Buffalo or send them a mail about that. I have never been in this situation .

Attorney response

If you plead guilty or are found guilty, the violation will appear on your record due to a reciprocity agreement between New York and Ontario. A New York traffic ticket attorney can handle everything and appear in court in your place as necessary.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding in a 55 MPH Zone

Posted by Anonymous · August 13, 2024

I was just notified to appear for a speeding ticket from over two years ago. Is that valid? I was given a ticket during Covid for 78 in a 55. I showed up to court on the date I was supposed to, they had everyone there just drop the papers in a box (it was during Covid) and leave. More than 2 years later I receive a letter telling me to show up to town court for a ‘conference’. Is this still valid?

Attorney response

In general, after two years, a ticket should be dismissed on speedy trial grounds. However, the statute of limitations was “tolled” during COVID, so it really depends on the exact timeline.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding in a 55 MPH Zone

Posted by Anonymous · September 24, 2024

What can do to fight a 41 mph+ speeding ticket and what are the odds that I won’t get my license revoked. I was traveling on I-87 and a state trooper was hiding under a commercial truck (coke truck) and pulled me over and I was clocked at 96 in a 55 speed limit zone.

Attorney response

Unless there are other things going on, a conviction will result in suspension, not revocation. Either way, few different things can be done to minimize the damage if handled properly

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(c), Speeding in a School Zone

Posted by Anonymous · June 8, 2024

I was given a ticket for speeding in a school zone and was wondering if it’s possible to get reduced. The ticket is for 38 mph in a 20 mph zone. I believe, it’s the only speeding ticket in work or school zone I have ever gotten. But I believe I have a speeding ticket from years ago but I also have 2 DWAI’s on my record that are both over ten years old. Will these affect my chances of a reduction or what would I have to do to be considered for a reduction as I have not had one in years

Attorney response

School zone speeding tickets are generally treated seriously by judges and prosecutors. They carry double fines and stay on your record for longer than a regular speeding ticket. It is possible to get it reduced if handled properly.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(c), Speeding in a School Zone

Posted by Anonymous · June 24, 2024

Will I get a reduction in points from a judge for speeding 14 mph over the limit in a school zone? No tickets in 14 yrs.

Attorney response

A judge cannot reduce points. A judge can only accept or reject a plea offer that is agreed upon between you and the prosecutor. School zone speeding tickets are serious. It might be best to get an attorney involved.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(c), Speeding in a School Zone

Posted by Anonymous · December 20, 2024

I got a speeding ticket in Brooklyn for driving 37 in a 25 mph school zone, which is 12 mph over. I honestly did not know I was in a school zone. I want to plead not guilty. What should I do?

Attorney response

If you got the ticket from a camera, then it does not have points and does not go on your record. If you got the ticket from a police officer, then you should fight it.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1180(f), Speeding in a Work Zone

Posted by Anonymous · June 24, 2024

Will my fine be more because arrest type is work zone? I got pulled over for speeding. I was speeding before the work zone but slowed down for the work zone. My ticket doesn't say speeding in a work zone, just that the arrest type is work zone. What is that and will that mean a more steep fine?

Attorney response

For DMV purposes, it is only considered a work zone ticket if the statute on the ticket is 1180(f). If there is another letter after 1180 and it is not an f, then it is not a work zone ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1180(f), Speeding in a Work Zone

Posted by Anonymous · October 28, 2024

I got two speeding tickets in two days for speeding in a work zone. I need a lawyer because I want to lose my license.

Attorney response

If you got them from a camera, then you don't need a lawyer and should pay them. If you got them from traffic stops, then it is much more serious. You are facing steep fines, suspension, and increased insurance rates.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1180(f), Speeding in a Work Zone

Posted by Anonymous · October 30, 2024

I got a letter in the mail for speeding in a work zone.. Should I get a lawyer or just pay ?

Attorney response

Camera tickets that come in the mail do not go on your driving record and should not impact your driving privileges.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1192(2), Driving While Intoxicated

Posted by Anonymous · October 16, 2025

Is a lawyer's presence required in court when my DWI probation ends in New York?

Attorney response

For any court appearances related to DWI charges, the court expects both defendant and their attorney in court

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1192(2), Driving While Intoxicated

Posted by Anonymous · May 24, 2026

How can I replace my lawyer in a DWI case in Nassau County before sentencing if they refuse to withdraw?

Attorney response

It is not up to the lawyer, but you and the court. I would suggest getting a new lawyer lined up first and having your new lawyer handle taking over the case.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1192(2), Driving While Intoxicated

Posted by Anonymous · June 21, 2026

What type of attorney should be consulted for challenging a DWI plea in New York based on issues with legal representation?

Attorney response

You need a criminal defense attorney that handles appeals.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1194(1)(b), Refusal of Breath Screening Test

Posted by Anonymous · June 20, 2024

Do i have to retake my road and written test in order to reapply for a drivers license after revocation from a DWAI? I got a DWAI 5 years ago in 2019. I had an automatic 1 year loss of license after refusing the breathalyzer. I still have not paid my civil penalties, but should be able to in a month or two. Once I pay my civil penalties, do I have to retake the road test/written test to get my license back? Or can I have it just restored once I pay the penalties?

Attorney response

No you just need to apply to get restored https://dmv.ny.gov/abctickets/how-request-restoration-after-driver-license-revocation

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1211(a), Backing Unsafely or Unsafe Backing

Posted by Anonymous · December 22, 2017

Can I get my New York junior license restored before my 60-day suspension ends? My license was suspended for 60 days after I received two speeding tickets and a ticket for backing up related to an accident. Is there any way to have it reinstated early?

Attorney response

You could attempt to have the underlying convictions vacated. Even if that is possible, though, the process would likely take more time than simply waiting out the 60-day suspension.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1211(b), Backing on a Controlled-Access Highway

Posted by Anonymous · December 1, 2018

I was in a parking lot backing out of my spot and bumped into a car behind me. I had waited for two or three cars to go by and was moving slowly, but the other car was there as I continued backing out. I was not all the way out of the space when it happened. The officer gave me a ticket for unsafe backing. I want to fight it, but what fines or points could I be facing?

Attorney response

An unsafe-backing charge under VTL 1211(a) carries 2 points and can result in a fine of up to $243. A lawyer may be able to appear in court for you and seek a resolution with hopefully no points.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1211(b), Backing on a Controlled-Access Highway

Posted by Anonymous · October 17, 2019

Could an NYC ticket under VTL 1211(a) be thrown out if I backed up in an intersection while turning left? I had a green light and misjudged a left turn at a narrow intersection. To keep my right front tire from going onto the sidewalk, I backed up a little so I could finish the turn. Larger vehicles like buses and trucks sometimes have to do this when making turns in the city. The officer gave me the ticket solely because people who wanted to cross had to wait. I did not see anyone whose movement I blocked or put at risk. I stayed in the roadway and did…

Attorney response

The fine is $138, but the points are more important and usually more costly. Your narrative is not particularly helpful. However, a lawyer can appear in court for you and can challenge the ticket for legal insufficiency or find other grounds for dismissal.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1211(b), Backing on a Controlled-Access Highway

Posted by Anonymous · November 8, 2019

I am a CDL-A hazmat driver, and I am worried that this unsafe-backing ticket could hurt my career. What is the best way to fight it, and what penalties might I be facing? I was delivering heating oil in a straight truck on a two-lane road. As I approached the delivery location, I put on my hazard lights. I stopped just beyond the house to make sure I had the correct address, then started backing toward the driveway. I did not realize a car had stopped directly behind my truck. It was close enough that I could not see it in any mirror. I backed up very…

Attorney response

Because your CDL affects your ability to earn a living, it is worth contesting this type of ticket as strongly as possible. An experienced traffic-ticket lawyer can give you the strongest chance of defeating the charge and may be able to appear in court for you when needed. A…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1211(b), Backing on a Controlled-Access Highway

Posted by Anonymous · May 6, 2024

Could I face any additional penalty because my traffic fine was paid one minute after the deadline? I had until April 30 to pay a fine for unsafe backing, but I forgot until late that night. The online payment posted at 12:01 a.m. on May 1. My plea paperwork says that not paying could lead to a civil judgment. Since I paid the entire amount, even though it was technically late, can that still happen?

Attorney response

No.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1225-c(2)(a), Cell Phone Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · December 20, 2024

I have a New York driver license, but I was ticketed in New Jersey for talking on a cell phone. Will New York put points on my license for that ticket?

Attorney response

It is our understanding that, for a Class D license, out-of-state cell phone violations will not appear on your New York record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1225-c(2)(a), Cell Phone Ticket

Posted by Anonymous · February 19, 2025

Should I plead not guilty to a texting while driving ticket in New York to possibly receive a plea bargain?

Attorney response

Texting while driving is a serious offense in New York, potentially affecting your record and resulting in fines. Pleading not guilty may offer a chance for a plea bargain, often negotiated by a traffic attorney who can also represent you in court. Consulting with a lawyer could…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1227(1), Consumption of Alcohol or Cannabis in a Vehicle

Posted by Anonymous · April 3, 2018

What are the possible fines for an open container ticket in Port Jefferson, NY?

Attorney response

If you received a ticket for possessing an open alcohol container in Port Jefferson, NY, the fine can vary. While some may handle similar situations with a minimal fine, others face up to $750 if they do not appear in court or negotiate a different outcome. Consulting an attorney…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1227(1), Consumption of Alcohol or Cannabis in a Vehicle

Posted by Anonymous · December 24, 2025

What are the potential legal consequences in New York for driving with a blood alcohol content of 0.08% and having an open container of alcohol in the car?

Attorney response

In New York, driving with a blood alcohol content (BAC) of 0.08% can lead to a DWI charge, which may result in fines, license suspension, and possible jail time. Having an open container of alcohol in the car can add further penalties. It's advisable to consult a local DWI…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1227(1), Consumption of Alcohol or Cannabis in a Vehicle

Posted by Anonymous · April 30, 2026

What can I do if I receive an open container ticket while sitting in my parked car in New York?

Attorney response

Receiving an open container ticket can affect your driving record and insurance rates. It's advisable to consult with an attorney who can explore your options for contesting the ticket and seek a favorable outcome in court.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1229-c, New York Seat Belt Laws

Posted by Anonymous · July 30, 2024

I got a citation while visiting New York State for my kid (8+) not wearing a seat belt. However, in the citation, it was mentioned to mail and didn’t see any fines. But the ticket was for front seat passenger improper seat belt, whereas my kid was sitting in rear driver seat. Should I add any explanation regarding this in that section before sending bacWould citation ? would there be any points for this? It was just unfortunate when my kid removed seat belt just before I being pulled over.

Attorney response

The fine is determined by the judge. An explanation will not amount to much except perhaps lower the fine a bit. The violation carries three points, will probably go onto your home state driving record, and will likely impact your car insurance rates. Best to challenge if…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1229‐C (1)(b), Back Seat Passenger Age 4-7 No/Improper Restraint

Posted by Anonymous · January 5, 2021

Is it possible to contest a New York ticket for improper restraint of young passengers if an adult was present in the back seat?

Attorney response

Yes, you can contest such a ticket. Legal representation may assist you effectively, and an attorney can appear in court on your behalf.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1229‐C (1)(b), Back Seat Passenger Age 4-7 No/Improper Restraint

Posted by Anonymous · July 9, 2025

What steps can I take to challenge a back-seat passenger seat belt ticket in New York State?

Attorney response

In New York, a seat belt violation for a passenger is not usually considered a moving violation and often doesn't impact your driving record. Contesting the ticket could involve negotiating with the prosecutor or attending court. Defensive driving courses generally apply to point…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1242-A, Operating E-Bike While Intoxicated

Posted by Anonymous · June 5, 2026

Can you get a dui on a battery powered bIke in the state of New York? I have a battery riding bike that I use to get around until I get a vehicle soon; it is dual manual as well as battery powered; if the battery dies out I can pedal manually. The battery speed only goes maybe 10mph My question is: could a police officer potentially charge me with a dui while riding my battery powered bike? thanks for the help.

Attorney response

The answer is yes, you could be charged. The above statute applies to any an ebike - something that is moved by something other than human power. If the motor is not running, and you are pedaling instead, then I would argue that, at the time of the operation, the bike was not a…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306-e, Fictitious Inspection Certificate

Posted by Anonymous · September 12, 2018

Could I face a felony charge for putting another vehicle’s registration sticker on my car? My friend had the car for about nine months. The inspection had run out around five months after he bought it, so he removed a sticker from an old car at work and used it temporarily while he was trying to repair the car and have it inspected again.

Attorney response

You could face criminal charges for that. It is a very bad idea.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306-e, Fictitious Inspection Certificate

Posted by Anonymous · July 11, 2019

What could happen if I return to court on my own for a misdemeanor involving an inspection sticker I did not know was fake? I was pulled over for allegedly going 45 in a 30 while driving downhill. I have a clean record. The officer said the system showed no inspection since February 2018, but my husband had the car inspected. Then the officer said the sticker was fraudulent. I brought my inspection receipt to court, but the judge did not look at it. The judge said it was a misdemeanor, told me to come back, and asked whether I could hire an attorney. I…

Attorney response

The most severe possible consequence is jail, although that is unlikely. A more realistic concern if the matter is not handled correctly is ending up with a permanent criminal record. Hiring a capable attorney would be a worthwhile investment.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306-e, Fictitious Inspection Certificate

Posted by Anonymous · February 20, 2020

What kind of fine am I looking at for VTL 306E? I was using my boyfriend's vehicle and later found out he had put a phony inspection sticker on it. I had no idea about that. I'm 70 and honestly do not keep track of the car's maintenance. The tickets were for VTL 306B and 306E. What could happen to me?

Attorney response

The judge sets the actual amount. The maximum fine for VTL 306B is $243, while VTL 306E can carry up to $393. More significantly, though, a 306E allegation is a criminal matter.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306-e, Fictitious Inspection Certificate

Posted by Anonymous · February 21, 2020

Can I get arrested in New York for driving a car with an inspection sticker that turned out to be illegal if I had no idea? An officer saw the sticker, said it was fake, but did not tell me why. I was handcuffed, arrested, photographed, fingerprinted, and charged with third-degree criminal possession, which I was told is a felony. I do not own the car. Can I still be charged and have this put on my record?

Attorney response

That is not the usual charge under these facts, but the arrest may fall within the officer's discretion. The officer was not required to tell you, during the arrest, what facts led him to believe the sticker was fraudulent. Whether there was sufficient probable cause for your…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306-e, Fictitious Inspection Certificate

Posted by Anonymous · June 6, 2024

Are police officers allowed to ask for social security number when being pulled over? I was pulled over because my inspection sticker to my vehicle that was purchased from a car shop was fake without my knowledge. .I gave the police my license and registration he then went to proceed to ask me for my SSN which I didn't understand what he needed for when he wrote me a ticket for my inspection sticker

Attorney response

They're allowed to ask – you do not have to answer any questions except provide your driver’s license, registration, and proof of insurance. You need to be careful not to drive with fake inspection stickers. You're bound to get pulled over, and you can get hit with criminal…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306(b), No Inspection Certificate (Uninspected Motor Vehicle)

Posted by Anonymous · July 25, 2024

Hi i got a ticket from a Yonkers police officer for an expired inspection sticker . problem is that I was parked on the Bronx side. Across the street is the Yonkers side.? I have several witnesses to the placement of the ticket and where I was parked, on the Bronx side.

Attorney response

Plead not guilty, have the case scheduled for trial, and bring your witnesses to testify that the car was parked in The Bronx. But first, determine whether it is cost-effective. Parking tickets do not go on your record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 306(b), No Inspection Certificate (Uninspected Motor Vehicle)

Posted by Anonymous · August 17, 2024

I just received a ticket in N.Y.S. for an overdue inspection sticker that I was unaware of while driving my girlfriend's car.... The sticker is also partially obstructed by the front window defroster strips that blocked full view of sticker.

Attorney response

Under New York law, the driver is responsible for ensuring that the car is in proper legal condition before driving the car. The ticket was issued against you, and you are responsible. It is always best to challenge such tickets if possible. They don't have points but will go on…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 319-1, Driving Without Insurance

Posted by Anonymous · July 1, 2024

My car was left by a family member parked on the sidewalk and was accumulating many tickets. If I didn't move the car it was going to be towed . At the time of moving the car some lady decided to put her toes under the moving vehicle. Cops was called and I received a no insurance and a no registration ticket. I work for New Jersey Transit and need my license to work . What's the odds of me getting a dismissal or lowered penalty?

Attorney response

No insurance is one of the worst tickets you can get. A conviction is mandatory revocation. There are some possible defenses, though, in your case.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 319-1, Driving Without Insurance

Posted by Anonymous · July 4, 2024

I got a ticket driving with no insurance do I plead guilty or not guilty? I brought my brother's truck to go to the junkyard and I thought there were insurance on it.

Attorney response

If you plead guilty, then your license will be revoked for a year. This is a ticket that must be fought in order to save your license.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 319-1, Driving Without Insurance

Posted by Anonymous · September 11, 2024

Is there anything I can do to prevent my license from revoked for not having insurance? Car was parked I was sitting in driver seat smoking a cigarette. The cigarette fell to the floor I dropped the hand brake to retrieve the cigarette. The car rolled a few inched and a lady claimed that my car hit her, which not entirely true. She call the police and I received a ticket operating with no insurance went to court found guilty

Attorney response

This should have been handled by an attorney from day one. At this point, the best bet is to file an appeal and request a Stay on the revocation. An attorney can help.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(12-a)(b), Window Tint Violations

Posted by Anonymous · August 13, 2024

I got a window tints ticket in NYC even though the tint reader was reading more than 30%? How do I fight this? The cop stated that I needed to get a 70 to pass. But that makes no sense as tint meters display how much light it blocks.

Attorney response

You need to submit a not guilty plea and schedule a hearing. This link provides more information on the Traffic Violations Bureau

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(12-a)(b), Window Tint Violations

Posted by Anonymous · October 28, 2024

I was pulled over and received two tickets, one for no inspection and one for tint. But but I received in the mail a notice of three tickets, one for no- inspection and two for window tints. What can I do since I was only given two at the scene And I have a recorded on video.

Attorney response

Technically, if you were not served with the traffic ticket, it should be dismissed because CPL requires personal service of traffic tickets.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(12-a)(b), Window Tint Violations

Posted by Anonymous · November 8, 2024

was on my way to pick up my children when there was a random checkpoint. My front windows were fully down when I was asked to pull over. The officer stated her name and made me aware that I was being recorded. She then requested my license and registration, which I provided. She saw my rear windows and stated that NYS law that front windows are to be at 100% visibility. My front windows were down and not only that, she quoted the law wrong. “Section 375 (12-a) states that the windshield and front side windows cannot block more than 30% of the light. She…

Attorney response

I don't see anything "illegal”, but there appear to be several grounds to challenge these tickets. The good news is that these do not have points and don't go on your record. Cops take these very seriously because laws prohibiting tint were intended for their safety.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375-2(a)(1), No/Inadequate Lights

Posted by Anonymous · September 6, 2019

I got stopped because the officer said one of my brake lights was out, but when I checked later it looked like it was working. I'm 19 and this was my first time being pulled over. I was on my way to school when a police car followed me for a bit. At a red light, they put on the lights and siren, and I did not realize right away they meant me. An officer came to my window, said I had a tail light out, and asked whether I knew about it. I said no. He asked where I was headed, and I said school. I gave him my license, and he went back to the police car. The…

Attorney response

That is unusual. It is possible the officers had to respond to something else and did not return. Based on what you described, it does not sound like you did anything wrong.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375-2(a)(1), No/Inadequate Lights

Posted by Anonymous · November 7, 2019

How should I respond to a New York traffic ticket for a bad tail light after I had it repaired? I got a uniform traffic ticket outside NYC because one of my taillights was broken. I was not stopped for speeding. The officer said I should repair it within a day, so I went to the local police department the following morning and had an officer sign my equipment-defect correction statement. The office there told me to enter a not-guilty plea, but I am unsure how to fill out and mail the ticket because I live in another state.

Attorney response

Enter a not-guilty plea and include documentation showing that the tail light was repaired.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375-2(a)(1), No/Inadequate Lights

Posted by Anonymous · September 10, 2020

I got a New York ticket for a bad taillight and was told that, after repairing it, I could have an inspection station verify the repair. The light has been fixed, but inspection places in Massachusetts have no idea what a "fix it" ticket is or how to sign it off. What should I do now? I really do not want to make a seven-hour trip each way just to show that the taillight was repaired.

Attorney response

Keep paperwork showing the taillight was repaired, such as a receipt or a letter from the shop. If that is not accepted, you can plead guilty. You could also retain an attorney to appear in court for you, although that may not be worthwhile for a minor ticket. There is no reason…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375-2(a)(1), No/Inadequate Lights

Posted by Anonymous · November 24, 2020

How do I contest a ticket for having no or inadequate tail lamps? Right before the officer stopped me, I switched my lights off and then back on. There is a problem with the front ballast, so the lights shut off only briefly before coming back on. My headlights and taillights are not actually out.

Attorney response

Even a short lapse in the lights operating can technically violate the law, so that explanation may not succeed as a defense. To challenge the ticket, plead not guilty, appear in court, and require the officer to prove each required part of the charge. Since this is a no-point…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(31), No or Inadequate Muffler

Posted by Anonymous · November 24, 2020

I was pulled over while merging onto the parkway even though I was at the speed limit and not revving my engine. The officer gave me a ticket for an inadequate muffler. Should I repair it and plead not guilty, or just plead guilty and pay? I have seen amounts from $150 online to $500 or $1,000—what could the fine be?

Attorney response

The judge determines the fine. The maximum is $150, plus a $63 surcharge. Since it does not have points, it is probably not worth the hassle of disputing.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(31), No or Inadequate Muffler

Posted by Anonymous · May 14, 2021

How much time does an officer have to file a ticket? I was stopped on January 11, 2020, and received a ticket for a loud exhaust, with a court date of February 7. When I went to court, the clerk told me there was no ticket in the system and that this occasionally happens, so I thought it was over. More than a year later, on April 20, 2021, I got a license-suspension notice for failing to answer the ticket. The city court told me the officer did not enter it until March 11, 2020, nearly a month after the scheduled court date. They removed the suspension…

Attorney response

Being filed three months after the ticket is issued is not, in and of itself, grounds for dismissal, but the wrong return date on the ticket might be a procedural defect that requires dismissal.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(31), No or Inadequate Muffler

Posted by Anonymous · May 26, 2021

The court sent my ticket back after I fixed an inadequate muffler. I had the repair done on the next business day, and the mechanic completed the proof-of-correction form. I mailed that paperwork to the town court along with a not-guilty plea because I thought getting it repaired on time usually meant the ticket would be dismissed. Instead, the court returned it with a note saying that, since the muffler was inadequate when I was stopped, I need to plead guilty. Can the court tell me which plea to enter?

Attorney response

I assume you were given a roadside reduction, and the court staff does not want the charge dismissed after the repair. The statute is on your side. The court should not act as law enforcement, and the ticket must be dismissed if the qualifying equipment violation was corrected by…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 375(31), No or Inadequate Muffler

Posted by Anonymous · July 21, 2022

A few days ago, I received three tickets in Brooklyn related to window tint and an inadequate exhaust. When I try searching for them on the Traffic Violations Bureau website, it says the ticket numbers cannot be found. I called the DMV, and support told me to wait a few days, but that time has passed already. I know I have 15 days to answer the tickets, but I have read that they sometimes take more than 15 days to show up online. What should I do? None of the tickets list a fine. I live in Pennsylvania and have a Pennsylvania license. I also question the…

Attorney response

It may take several weeks before the tickets appear in the system. You can mail in the Not Guilty plea. Not necessarily worth contesting violations that do not have points or appear on your driving record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 401, No Registration or Expired Registration

Posted by Anonymous · May 21, 2024

Is there a specific time during which a car can be ticketed for expired registration in NY?

Attorney response

If your vehicle was registered at the time of the ticket, but you hadn’t displayed the registration, you may have grounds to contest it. Provide evidence that the registration was valid at that time. Parking enforcement can issue tickets at any time, so it’s essential to check…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 401, No Registration or Expired Registration

Posted by Anonymous · May 29, 2024

How can I defend against tickets for no registration and insurance issues in NY?

Attorney response

Given the seriousness of these tickets, such as no registration and insurance discrepancies, it's advisable to consult a traffic ticket attorney. These offenses can lead to significant penalties, including criminal charges and a possible revocation of your driving privileges. An…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 401, No Registration or Expired Registration

Posted by Anonymous · July 22, 2025

Can a tenant legally park a car with expired registration in their private driveway in New York?

Attorney response

In New York, you can park a vehicle with expired registration on private property, such as a driveway. The restriction on registration primarily applies to operating the vehicle on public roads, not parking it on private land.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 402(b), Obscured and Obstructed License Plates

Posted by Anonymous · October 6, 2018

An officer gave me a ticket for my dealer license-plate frame instead of a speeding ticket because I have a clean record. If I enter a not-guilty plea for the plate obstruction charge, do I need to appear in court?

Attorney response

If you plead not guilty, you generally have to appear in court afterwards unless you retain an attorney who can go to court in your place.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 402(b), Obscured and Obstructed License Plates

Posted by Anonymous · February 1, 2019

What should I do about a ticket for having a dirty license plate? A state trooper stopped me for speeding, but instead of writing me for speeding, he gave me a ticket because my plate was dirty.

Attorney response

Would need to see the ticket to say for sure, but in general, charges under “dirty plate” do not carry points or appear on your driving record.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 402(b), Obscured and Obstructed License Plates

Posted by Anonymous · January 9, 2021

What am I likely to have to pay, and does this ticket put points on my license? I was stopped for doing 85 in a 65. The officer wrote me up for having a dirty license plate instead, although the ticket also lists my speed and says general 101a. I’m trying to find out what the charge will cost and whether I’ll get license points.

Attorney response

Sounds like you got a roadside reduction, but an attorney would have to review the charging instruments to know for sure.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 402(b), Obscured and Obstructed License Plates

Posted by Anonymous · August 31, 2023

Can I legally be stopped because my temporary Arizona tag was inside a plastic cover and the officer said he could not see the state or issue information? When I showed him the information on the back, he said the cover obstructed the tag. I was ultimately ticketed for having no insurance, which I did not have then, and for a scented air freshener hanging from my mirror. Was there a valid reason for the stop, or were my rights violated?

Attorney response

If the officer could not see your plate information, it would appear that the traffic stop was valid. Having no insurance is the most serious ticket as it carries mandatory revocation if you plead guilty or are found guilty.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 512, Operating While Registration Is Suspended or Revoked

Posted by Anonymous · November 7, 2024

What should I expect when I go to court? New York State—I got a ticket for suspended registration because of an insurance lapse, under VTL 512. I had insurance again when I was stopped, and the officer said to fix the registration right away before letting me leave. The lapse was only for a few days. DMV gave me the option to surrender my plates or pay $72 to restore the registration. I paid the $72, and my registration was reinstated the following day, so I am legal to drive now. But I still have a court date. The ticket calls this a misdemeanor, which…

Attorney response

VTL 512 is a criminal charge https://upstatenewyorktickets.com/blog/vtl-512-driving-with-a-suspended-registration.html It is probably something that should be taken seriously.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 512, Operating While Registration Is Suspended or Revoked

Posted by Anonymous · December 6, 2024

How do I get an old traffic matter taken off my driving abstract? It is causing a problem with a background check. My abstract still lists a suspended license and suspended registration, even though I paid the court fines. I did not understand then that this could keep affecting me later. I got a certificate of disposition from the court, but the background-check company will not accept it. They told me they cannot hire me while it remains on my driving abstract. I am having a hard time finding work and am in serious financial trouble. The tickets…

Attorney response

Having a suspended registration does not show up on a driving record. Driving with a suspended registration is a criminal offense and you should have had an attorney at that time and if you could not afford an attorney the court was supposed to appoint one for you…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 600(1)(a), Leaving the Scene of an Incident With Property Damage

Posted by Linda · July 26, 2026

What if the other guy threatens you

Attorney response

"Self-defense" or similar is a sufficient defense but has to be proven. If you leave the scene because you feel threatened, you should contact the police and return to the scene with the police.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 605, Failure to Report an Accident to the DMV

Posted by Anonymous · December 15, 2024

I live in New York and was charged in New Jersey with not reporting an accident. The prosecutor is offering a plea where I would pay a fine but get no points or suspension in New Jersey. If I plead guilty, could New York suspend my license after it receives the conviction?

Attorney response

As far as I know it is only automatic revocation for CDL driver. https://suspendedlicensenyc.com/blog/vtl-600-1a.html

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1128(a), Unsafe Lane Change

Posted by Anonymous · September 7, 2020

How can I contest an unsafe lane change ticket under VTL 1128(a)? I was stopped between intersections, across from a turn lane. Because I was under the signal, I could not tell whether the traffic light was green. The pedestrian signal on the other side showed a hand. There was only one other car, about 300 feet from the turn lane, while I was roughly 100 feet away. Since traffic was almost empty and that intersection gets very crowded, I made the turn quickly because it seemed safe. The other car turned out to be a police officer, and it accelerated to…

Attorney response

Simply giving the court your account of what happened, even if it is entirely accurate, usually will not be enough. In many cases, the court will credit the officer's account. The focus is generally on finding a problem in the officer's case, such as an inconsistency, a missing…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1128(a), Unsafe Lane Change

Posted by Anonymous · November 19, 2022

Should I just pay an unsafe lane-change ticket in New York, or should I contest it in traffic court? I was merging onto a highway and thought there was enough room, but a tractor-trailer hit my car. That impact pushed me into the vehicle ahead of me. Mine was the only car that was damaged, yet I received a ticket, and it looks like I am being blamed for the three-car crash. I thought New York being no-fault mattered here. Would it make more sense to appear in court and try for a reduced charge, or pay the ticket, accept the points, and take an online…

Attorney response

New York being a “no fault” state has to do with insurance coverage, not traffic violations. Taking a defensive-driving class will not erase points from your license. The crash itself may raise your insurance costs, and a moving violation on your record could make that worse. It…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1128(a), Unsafe Lane Change

Posted by Anonymous · May 6, 2024

I need help understanding what happens after a family member had a crash on the highway around 4:00 AM. It was dark and raining, and they were traveling in the far-left lane when they came upon a disabled car sitting there with no lights on and nobody inside. They tried to move right to avoid the disabled car, but struck the rear of a vehicle traveling in the next lane. What should they do now?

Attorney response

What is the specific problem you need addressed? If your family member received a traffic ticket, they should take it to a traffic attorney.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1128(a), Unsafe Lane Change

Posted by Anonymous · July 12, 2024

My 17-year-old son, driving on a junior license, got pulled over for an unsafe lane change. The cop could have also written him a ticket for driving past 9:00 PM, since it was midnight. My question is, if I fight this ticket, will they look at the ticket and say no and tack on the after-hours driving charge?

Attorney response

That is theoretically possible but not likely. Best to risk it and fight the ticket because junior license holders have to be more careful about getting violations on their record, and they have a lower threshold for suspension. See…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1128(a), Unsafe Lane Change

Posted by Anonymous · September 26, 2024

I’ve got a traffic ticket for violation code 1128(a)- move from lane unsafely. I chose to plead not guilty, and I don’t have time to appear in person for a court trial. I need a lawyer to represent me to be there.

Attorney response

An attorney can handle this case in your place and should be able to get it reduced or dismissed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1180(a), Speed Not Reasonable and Prudent

Posted by Anonymous · January 5, 2025

I received a ticket for "speed not reasonable and prudent." I was going 55 in a 40 mph area. The officer said he would not put the actual speed on the ticket and told me I could fight it. Would pleading guilty put points on my license? It was clear out, the road was empty, and it was around 10 p.m. I was just driving along and did not realize I was that far over the limit. I am not sure what I should do.

Attorney response

Three points on your record and likely increased insurance rates. https://www.trafficlawyerlongisland.com/blog/vtl1180a.html An attorney can go to court in your place and should be able to get it reduced to a parking ticket or dismissed.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL 1180(b), Speeding Over the Maximum Limit

Posted by Anonymous · December 5, 2024

I was cited in Suffolk County for driving 100 mph in a 55 mph zone while I was on my way to a relative's funeral. I know my driving history does not look good: I had two speeding tickets in May 2021 and an electronic-device ticket in October 2021. I have not received any tickets in the last three years. Is there any chance this ticket could be reduced?

Attorney response

This is a serious ticket. A speeding charge of 35 mph over the speed limit is an 8 point speeding ticket. The fine ranges from $273 to $693 with the exact amount being up to the judge. There is also an additional mandatory $450 Driver Responsibility Assessment Fee from New York…

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1213(a), Driver’s View Obstructed

Posted by Anonymous · June 26, 2018

Can a district attorney get a traffic ticket dismissed in upstate New York? I received a ticket for an alleged rear-view obstruction under VTL 1213(a) near Corning. The trooper said I could respond to Chemung Town Court either by appearing or mailing in my response. I mailed a reduction request to the Chemung County DA's office. The DA then sent me a copy of a letter to the town court judge saying that, at the trooper's request, the office was asking for dismissal in the interest of justice. Do I need to notify the court myself? Will the court send…

Attorney response

The DA does not dismiss the ticket alone; the court must approve the request, and the DA has asked the judge to do that. The court may mail you a confirmation. If you do not receive one, contact the court to check the status.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1213(a), Driver’s View Obstructed

Posted by Anonymous · September 29, 2019

I was stopped for speeding, but the officer wrote me a ticket for obstructed driver view under 1213(a) instead. Should I just plead guilty?

Attorney response

This violation carries 2 points, so it is generally better not to simply plead guilty. A lawyer can appear in court for you and attempt to challenge the ticket.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1213(a), Driver’s View Obstructed

Posted by Anonymous · April 1, 2022

What is the purpose of the additional-information section on my ticket? I was stopped after allegedly driving 55 mph in a 35 mph area. The Broome County sheriff issued a ticket for an obstructed driver's view under VTL 1213(a) because I had an air freshener hanging from my rearview mirror. On the back, the additional information says I was driving 55 in the posted 35 zone and that the air freshener blocked my view. If I enter a not-guilty plea to the obstruction ticket, could I then be charged with speeding based on what the sheriff wrote there?

Attorney response

This needs to be handled carefully. In theory, yes, the speeding charge could be issued. However, you should not simply plead guilty to the VTL 1213(a) charge, which carries 2 points. Speak with a traffic-ticket attorney about the situation.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1213(a), Driver’s View Obstructed

Posted by Anonymous · August 15, 2023

What happens if I plead guilty to a ticket for having something hanging from my mirror that blocked my view? The officer gave me that ticket instead of ticketing me for speeding up to get around another car, and he did not seem familiar with my new Ontario plates.

Attorney response

Sounds like you got a "roadside reduction", which is not uncommon. The violation can be charged as VTL 375 or VTL 1213. A charge under VTL 1213 carries points.

1 replyOpen discussion
VTL § 1213(a), Driver’s View Obstructed

Posted by Anonymous · October 20, 2023

I received a ticket. The disposition notice lists it as a vehicle equipment violation, while the ticket says my view was obstructed. What does that mean?

Attorney response

You may have also been charged under VTL 1213(a), which carries 2 points or under VTL 375-22 which is a no point ticket. Show the documents to an attorney.

1 replyOpen discussion

Content on this website is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. Viewing this site does not create an attorney–client relationship.